States in India are considered as indestructible for the simple reason that the union has more power over the state than the state itself and at any point of time, the union could pass a bill to alter its territorial boundaries.
Who said India is an indestructible union of destructible states?
Thus, while states can be broken, reorganized by alternation of boundaries, the country is a union which cannot be broken. Central Government can change the name, boundaries of the states without their permission also. That is why Dr. B R Ambedkar called India as an “indestructible Union of destructible states”.
Why India is indestructible union of destructible states?
India as a union is indestructible in order to protect the sovereignty, integrity and unity. Units or states within the union cannot secede as there is no provision for it under the Constitution.
Why USA is indestructible union of indestructible states?
White, (1869), U.S. Supreme Court case in which it was held that the United States is “an indestructible union” from which no state can secede. The suit contended that the transfer of the bonds was illegal because the bonds were not signed by the governor, as required by federal law. …
Why is India called union of states?
The Constitution of India has established the federal form of Government in India. Therefore, it is called the Union of States. … Division of Powers: Like any other federal country, in India also the powers have been divided between the union and the States.
What is the Article 3 of the Indian Constitution?
Article 3, Draft Constitution, 1948
It empowered the Parliament to make law relating to the formation of new states and alteration of existing states. One member strongly believed that the proposal to alter an existing State must originate from the concerned State Legislature and not the parliament.
What was Berubari case?
Facts: In the case of Re Berubari Case, the States of Punjab and Bengal were to be partitioned. A commission was appointed as Sir Cyril Redcliffe as its chairman for apportionment of the state of Bihar. A boundary was fixed between India and Pakistan are known as the Redcliffe line.
What is indestructible union?
India has been called as “indestructible union” by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar as no Indian state can secede from the Indian union as in the case of confederation or loosely held federation.
What is Article 1 of the Indian Constitution?
Article 1 of the Constitution
Article 1 in the Constitution states that India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States. The territory of India shall consist of: The territories of the states, The Union territories and Any territory that may be acquired in future.
What is the difference between Indian and US Constitution?
The Constitution of US is more rigid than the Indian Constitution. While US has the Presidential form of Government, India has the Parliamentary form of Government. … Differences in the judicial system between US and India: While the US has an advanced judicial system, India has a rapidly developing judicial system.
Is USA destructible?
The US constitution, in all its provisions, looks to an” indestructible union composed of indestructible states “ while on the other hand India is a “indestructible union of destructible state”. Compare and contrast.
What’s the meaning of indestructible?
: incapable of being destroyed, ruined, or rendered ineffective.
Which country is not having the federal model of government?
China and Sri Lanka have a unitary form of government. Under the unitary system, either there is only one level of government or the sub-units are subordinate to the central government. The central government can pass on orders to the provincial or the local government.
Which is the India’s richest state?
|Rank||State/Union Territory||Nominal GDP ₹ lakh crore = INR trillions; USD billions|
|1||Maharashtra||₹32.24 lakh crore (US$450 billion)|
|2||Tamil Nadu||₹19.43 lakh crore (US$270 billion)|
|3||Uttar Pradesh||₹17.05 lakh crore (US$240 billion)|
|4||Karnataka||₹16.65 lakh crore (US$230 billion)|
Who is called Union of India?
Dominion of India (1947–1950) The Government of India, whose legal name is “Union of India” as per Article 300 of the Indian constitution.